Best Wood for an SG: Expert Opinion

Check out our free gear Marketplace!

The SG model is undoubtedly one of the most popular and replicated kinds of guitars since its conception.

It’s only natural that different manufacturers had imprinted their own signature on this guitar over the years, in their different takes.

And I can’t think of something that could change the personality of an instrument more than its tonewoods, and there are many SG models that rock different varieties of them, be it because of availability, cost cuts, or just a tonal search from the builder.

But what is the best wood for an SG?

Original SGs were made of mahogany and rosewood. These materials were selected mainly because of their availability and quality in the early ’60s. Nowadays, it’s harder to find high-quality specimens of these woods, so manufacturers gravitate to alternative ones such as okoume or korina.

In this article, I will tell you all you need to know about what makes an SG sound like an SG, and what alternatives might get you close to it.

After leaving this page you will have a clearer idea about how tonewoods work on an SG, what is the traditional take on the instrument, and what things you should look for when shopping for a great guitar.

Are you ready to get started?

Let’s go!

What makes for a great tonewood

Although tonewoods are debated among guitar players, especially for electric guitars, I’m a big proponent that they actually do make a difference.

However, we are not here to discuss that now.

Assuming that tonewoods are important for a guitar, it’s only natural to also accept that there might be different “qualities” of them in the wild.

And, although this quality I mention can be used to rank specific types of wood, or species (or anyway it should be said) such as Mahogany, Maple, Cedar, Rosewood, etc. or their different local variants (Indian Rosewood, Brazilian rosewood) I also think about it within slabs of the same kind.

You see, you can find two pieces of comparable trees of mahogany, however one has been cut very recently and the other one was stored for 70 years.

Join GearAficionado Market
Chords
Chords

In this case, you can expect that the older exemplar will probably be way better “stationed”, dryer, and more resonant for the use on a guitar.

This is a big tradeoff a lot of manufacturers have to think about nowadays with the current availability of woods, but I will touch on this later.

Legendary SGs were built with mahogany, and rosewood

As many of you might know, the SG was launched as a more modern, slimmer take on the Les Paul.

It even took its name for the first year or so.

The materials were almost the same, mahogany for the body and neck, and rosewood for the fingerboard, however, there was no maple top this time around.

Its thinner body, and tighter pickup spacing make for the SG to be more snappy, aggressive, and brighter sounding than its counterpart the Les Paul.

But was all of this a conscious decision made by Gibson after thorough research and experimentation?

Probably not.

It most likely was a way of cutting costs, thinking that the public wouldn’t miss the more expensive produce Les Paul, and a way to compete with Fender’s more stylized models that were taking on the market.

However, this mix of conditions shaped what’s nowadays one of the most sought-after guitar models ever that has shaped the sound of generations of legendary albums, and put a label on what we think an SG should sound like.

Buy and sell music gear for free on Gear Aficionado Market!

But is this all SGs should be?

The case for Okoume

Okoume is a hardwood native to Africa that’s commonly used as an alternative to mahogany.

It has a slightly brighter tone, particularly in the upper midrange, but this probably will be hard to notice on an electric guitar, however, this surely suits the more aggressive identity of the SG.

Many purists will turn away from “modern” alternatives such as this, but when the choice is to be made between a very young piece of mahogany or a well-stationed slab of Okoume, I would always go for the more mature alternative.

Other alternatives

Not only Okoume is nowadays used as a replacement for mahogany in many guitar models that don’t intend to be a truthful reissue of their classic counterparts.

It’s common to also find necks and bodies made of korina, koa, wenge, agathis, bubinga, walnut, and even basswood.

Pau ferro, baked maple, laurel, and even synthetics such as richlite can also be found as fingerboard tonewoods.

Is there anything wrong with this?

Again, not really. 

It’s just a slightly different flavor, and for electric guitars such as the SG, one could argue it might be even more of an aesthetic choice.

Quality vs availability

As I mentioned earlier, these days, with mass production in mind, manufacturers and artisans have to deal with a ubiquitous tradeoff between quality and availability.

Making a guitar with its vintage old specs it’s not economically possible in many cases, and in some others, not even legal.

From finishes to certain protected kinds of woods, manufacturers have to make compromises to deliver goods at a payable price point.

Mahogany is an expensive tonewood, and its demand has only grown with the years and its popularity as a material for luxury furniture.

This only causes available stocks to be young and not really well-fitted for guitar making.

A completely different scenario from what Gibson had to deal with in the early ‘60s when the SG was first prototyped.

One could argue that if such a guitar was designed in the current times, its builders will probably gravitate to some alternative kind of wood that is currently commonly available in conditions suited for guitar-making, such as the ones mentioned above.

Conclusion

There is no best wood for an SG since it mostly depends on the quality of the current slabs available. When the original runs were made, mahogany and rosewood were a great alternative, however, nowadays their quality is lacking. This is why manufacturers use substitute materials.